How Much Melamine Is Safe To Eat?
A Scary Question, But Marion Nestle Tries To Figure It Out During This Food Contamination Scare
The British Food Standards Agency has been checking on levels of melamine in sweets imported from China. Some candies contained as much as 152 milligrams melamine per kilogram (mg/kg) or parts per million (ppm).
A kg is 2.2 pounds, which would be a lot of candy to eat. Some of the tainted infant formula contained 2,500 mg/kg, but you only use a scoop (10 grams or so) to make up a bottle of infant formula, and that would contain 25 mg.
I realize that I am asking the wrong question--melamine should not be in food at all--but how much is safe to eat? To follow this, you have to pay close attention to the difference between mg/kg melamine in food versus the amount per kg body weight.
The FDA says 2.5 mg/kg in food is unlikely to be harmful in anything other than infant formula. The FDA’s May 2007 melamine risk assessment said 63 mg/kg body weight was safe for adults but it established a Tolerable Daily Intake (TDI) 100 times lower, or 0.63 mg/kg body weight per day. The European TDI is even lower: 0.5 mg/kg body weight per day.
Using the European TDI, a person weighing 80 kg (176 pounds) could supposedly safely consume 40 mg melamine from food a day. But a baby weighing 5 kg (12 pounds) drinking infant formula containing 25 mg melamine would be getting 5 mg/kg body weight with every bottle--ten times the European TDI. And babies drink several bottles a day. And if a by-product of melamine, cyanuric acid, is also present, kidney crystals can form at much lower concentrations.
All of this begs the question: how come it is there in the first place and what are the food safety agencies going to do about it? And when? In the meantime, food companies should be testing anything with protein in it for melamine and it’s best to avoid eating foods made in places where they aren’t doing such testing.
Marion Nestle
Noted author Marion Nestle is a Professor in the Department of Nutrition, Food Studies, and Public Health at New York University. She is the author of What to Eat.read full bio.
buy the book
What To Eat: Expert advice on food, health and nutrition issues that are in the news.
Comments | Add a comment
| so far.. |
|
Marion Nestle writes about her strong arguments in favor of public awareness ... read more.
rss
- Are Vegetarian and Vegan Diets Healthy?
- Would You Pay $8.50 a Gallon for Gas? Then Why Pay It for Soda?
- The Answers to 4 Perplexing Questions About Sugar, Fat and Calories
- Should You Be Eating Genetically Modified Corn?
- How Many Calories Do I Need to Eat to Gain One Pound?
- No, My Dog Is Not Destroying the Environment
- No, My Dog Is Not Destroying the Environment
- How Many Calories Do I Need to Eat to Gain One Pound?
- Forget "Food Miles." Eat Less Meat
- Would You Pay $8.50 a Gallon for Gas? Then Why Pay It for Soda?
- Myth or Fact? A Bill in Congress Will Mean the End of Organic Farming
- Michael Taylor Appointed to FDA: A Good choice!
|
||||||||||
 |
Enter your city or zip code to get your local temperature and air quality and find local green food and recycling resources near you.
|
 |
||||||||
 |
||||||||||
